Fiscal subject related
The transaction can be considered a service if the sale of the prepared food and drink is accompanied by appropriate additional services that allow immediate consumption on the spot; for example, dining facilities are provided with tables, chairs, and benches, and these service elements dominate the transaction. The sale of food and drink is therefore only one part of the transaction, in which services predominate.
In the transaction, the provision of services dominates if there is an opportunity for local consumption, and the guest lives with this; that is, he accepts the additional services that enable immediate consumption. However, if it is not possible to eat on-site or the guest asks for the food or drink to be taken away, then product sales dominate the transaction instead of service. That also means that the predominance of service provision can be realized not only in restaurant catering, in conditions typical of restaurant catering, but also, for example, in fast food restaurants, in the so-called "food courts" of shopping centers, where there is usually no service and guests have to take plastic trays and cutlery.
When determining the typical and dominant elements of the transaction, all the circumstances of the hospitality business must be taken into account, because only by evaluating them can it be decided whether the transaction is more of a product sale or more of a service provision. It is not the level of service provision that is decisive, but the service elements related to the given activity. Thus, the application of a reduced VAT rate for local consumption cannot be ruled out, even for services of a less advanced standard compared to restaurant catering. This is also supported by the Court's 2022 ruling, according to which the dominance of service provision cannot be established only in circumstances typical of restaurant catering.
Overall, it can be said that the existence of additional services must always be judged in relation to the nature of the given service. The specific activity must be examined and judged from the point of view of the average consumer.
Other news from Hungary
EU to protect domestic e-commerce sellers with a cross-border tax reform
As online shopping continues to grow, the European Union is planning to implement new regulations to protect local e-commerce sellers. One significant change affects consumers who shop on international platforms like Temu or AliExpress. The EU has already taken some steps at the first sign of growing foreign e-commerce sellers, and since July 1, 2021, all goods entering the EU, regardless of their... Read more
EU VAT Validation Tool
One way to validate VAT numbers in the EU is the VAT Information Exchange System (VIES), which is a crucial tool for businesses operating within the European Union. Owned by the European Commission, VIES is a search engine that retrieves data from national VAT databases to verify VAT numbers. Here’s a detailed look at how VIES works and its significance. How VIES Works When a search is made usi... Read more
Hungary's deposit return scheme now entering a new phase
Hungary started its environmental transformation with the launch of its deposit return system (shortened as DRS) starting this year. From this month, July 2024, Hungary entered the next phase of its DRS, with the end of its six-month transition period, during which time drink producers could place on the market beverage packaging both with and without deposit markings Read more
There are new e-cash registers in Hungary for the restaurant sector.
Hungary is set to implement e-cash register solutions tailored for various sectors. In catering establishments, these e-cash registers are exclusively for registering payments for services and handling orders from receipt to payment, with a mandatory consumption summary receipt issued. Read more
New document was uploaded: Overview of fiscalization in European countries
This document contains an overview of the presence of fiscalization and its types in all European countries. Read more
What is the process for customers to get e-receipts in Hungary going to look like?
In Hungary, downloading an e-receipt that will be used based on the new requirements (that will allow the usage of e-receipts as a receipt format) involves a straightforward process leveraging modern solutions. The IT background of the e-receipt has been developed in such a way that the customer will not need any special registration to use it. All he would need is a smartphone and the app downlo... Read more
Understanding Hungary's anti-shrinkflation decree for grocery retailers
Hungarian authorities have created an Amendment Act (Decree 1/2024) on measures needed to reduce food inflation and a new legislative framework. This legal update primarily addresses the growing issue of product shrinkflation, where the quantity of products is reduced while prices remain stable or increase, effectively lowering the value consumers get for their money. The regulation targets trader... Read more