Germany’s Higher Administrative Court of Lüneburg asked the ECJ to decide whether a QR code can replace a paper receipt from weighing scales, challenging the long-held view that only printed paper meets legal standards. The case could redefine receipt rules under EU law, focusing on whether digital formats still guarantee transparency, legibility, and customer protection.
Germany: Is a QR Code Enough Instead of a Paper Receipt?
Public
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Category:
Fiscal subject related
Views:
1923
Content accuracy validation date:
03.09.2025
Content accuracy validation time:
08:13h
In August 2025, the Higher Administrative Court of Lüneburg referred a question to the European Court of Justice (ECJ): must receipts from cash register scales always be printed on paper, or can a digital QR code also count?
The case:
A grocery store allowed customers to choose between a paper receipt or a QR code at its weighing scales. The Lower Saxony State Office for Metrology argued this violated the law, insisting only paper receipts are valid. It even threatened to revoke the calibration of the scales. The store appealed, but the Administrative Court ruled that paper receipts were mandatory.
The Measuring and Verification Ordinance (MessEV) and the EU Measuring Instruments Directive (2014/32/EU) require receipts to be "printed," clear, legible, and permanent. Traditionally, this has been understood to mean paper.
The debate:
- The Higher Administrative Court sees room for a broader interpretation.
- It noted that EU standards (DIN EN 45501:2015) describe printers only as one example of electronic devices and aim to be technology-neutral.
- The main purpose of the rule is customer protection: receipts must make transactions transparent and verifiable over time. A QR code could serve this purpose if customers have a choice.
The ECJ will now decide whether digital receipts, like QR codes, can replace paper receipts under EU law.
Other news from Germany
Germany Prepares New Rules on the Right to Repair
Public
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany is revising sales law to align with the EU Right to Repair Directive, aiming to facilitate product repairs over new purchases. Implementing this directive by July 31, 2026, manufacturers will be obligated to repair certain products during their lifecycle, even without direct contracts with consumers. Initial focus is on specific groups, with repairs needing to be affordable and timely. The... Read more
Germany: New Version of ZUGFeRD/Factur-X e-Invoice Format Released
Public
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
FeRD and FNFE-MPE released ZUGFeRD 2.5 / Factur-X 1.09, aligning with EN 16931's latest code lists and adding new elements. The German FeRD forum and the French FNFE-MPE forum have released a new version of their joint e-invoicing format, ZUGFeRD 2.5 / Factur-X 1.09. The update aligns the format with the latest code lists used under the European e-invoicing standard EN 16931. These code lists are... Read more
Germany Updates External Tax Audit Rules
Public
Germany
Author: Ema Stamenković
Germany
Author: Ema Stamenković
Germany’s new External Audit Regulations aim to modernize tax audits by making them faster, more coordinated and risk-focused, while updating cooperation and group audit rules. Germany’s Federal Cabinet adopted new External Audit Regulations. The new rules will replace the old Tax Audit Ordinance from 2000 and reflect recent changes in German tax procedure law, including the DAC7 Implementat... Read more
Germany Discusses “21–10–0” VAT Reform
Public
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany is reportedly considering a VAT reform from January 1, 2027, which could raise the standard and reduced VAT rates while applying 0% VAT to basic food products. Germany is reportedly considering a major VAT reform that would shift part of the tax burden from income to consumption. Under the proposal, the standard VAT rate would increase from 19% to 21%, while the reduced VAT rate would ris... Read more
Germany Confirms Email can be Used for E-Invoices, but PDF Alone is not Enough
Public
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany allows e-invoices to be sent by email, but the attached invoice must be in a compliant structured format such as XRechnung or ZUGFeRD with XML, while ordinary PDFs, scans, Word/Excel files, or invoice text in the email body do not qualify as legal e-invoices. Germany allows businesses to send e-invoices by email, but only if the invoice is attached in a legally valid structured format. A s... Read more
Germany Introduces New Withdrawal Button for Online Consumer Contracts
Public
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany’s new mandatory withdrawal button will require online B2C businesses to provide consumers with a clear, permanently available electronic way to withdraw from distance contracts from 19 June 2026. Businesses must update websites, apps, platforms, confirmation messages, and internal processes to support clear withdrawal submission, confirmation, and possible partial withdrawal. Germany has f... Read more
Germany Clarifies Rules for Compliant E-Invoices
Public
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany clarified that compliant e-invoices and credit notes must be self-contained, with all mandatory VAT information included in the structured electronic file itself. Businesses should review invoice templates and ERP systems to avoid relying only on PDFs, links, or separate documents for required invoice data. Germany’s Ministry of Finance has updated its e-Invoicing FAQs to clarify tha... Read more