The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that the French electricity transmission charge (TBV) does not constitute an “other indirect tax” under Directive 2008/118/EC because it is not directly linked to the quantity of electricity consumed.
The judgment clarifies that tariff-based levies, even if passed on to consumers, fall outside EU excise duty rules when they are calculated independently of actual consumption, providing guidance for similar energy-sector charges.
EU Court Rules on Classification of French Electricity Transmission Charge
Public
France
Author: Vukašin Santo
Category:
Fiscal subject related
Views:
41
Content accuracy validation date:
12.02.2026
Content accuracy validation time:
08:35h
The Court has ruled that the French electricity transmission levy (TBV) does not qualify as an “other indirect tax” within the meaning of Article 1(2) of Directive 2008/118/EC. The decision clarifies that the TBV is calculated independently of the actual quantity of electricity consumed.
France introduced the tariff-based contribution for electricity transmission (TBV) in 2004. Accorinvest and Société Générale SA (SG SA), as final consumers of electricity, challenged the levy and sought a refund of the amounts paid. They argued that the TBV should be classified as an “other indirect tax” under Article 1(2) of Directive 2008/118/EC, which would make it incompatible with EU excise duty rules.
The French national court referred preliminary questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), which subsequently referred the case to the General Court.
In its judgement, the Court held that the TBV does not fall within the scope of “other indirect taxes” as defined by the Directive. A key factor in the Court’s reasoning was that the levy is not directly linked to electricity consumption, as it is calculated independently of the actual volume of electricity consumed.
The Court further emphasized that the mere existence of a legal mechanism allowing the TBV to be passed on to the final consumer does not, in itself, establish a direct and inseparable link between the levy and electricity consumption. As a result, the TBV cannot be classified as an “other indirect tax” within the meaning of EU excise duty legislation.
The ruling provides important clarification on the distinction between consumption-based taxes and tariff-based levies in the energy sector and has implications for the assessment of similar charges under EU tax law.
Other news from France
New document was uploaded: Tax Audit in France: Current state and upcoming changes
France
Author: Vukašin Santo
The purpose of this document is to explain rules regarding the tax audit regime in France, what the central point of a tax audit is, what the procedure is, and also what will change with new E-invoicing and E-reporting obligations. Read more
Subscribe to get access to the latest news, documents, webinars and educations.
Already subscriber? Login
France’s September 2026 E-Invoicing Mandate in Doubt After Finance Bill Blocked
Public
France
Author: Vukašin Santo
France
Author: Vukašin Santo
France’s planned September 1, 2026 mandatory e-invoicing rollout is now uncertain after the 2026 Finance Bill failed to pass in December 2025, meaning none of the approved e-invoicing provisions are legally in force in France. Although Article 28 was approved by the National Assembly and the Senate, a temporary budget is extending 2025 rules into 2026, with a political compromise expected by mid-F... Read more
France Publishes List of Approved E-Invoicing Platforms
Public
France
Author: Vukašin Santo
France
Author: Vukašin Santo
France’s e-invoicing reform relies on state-approved intermediary platforms, with the General Directorate of Public Finances (DGFiP) publishing an official list and logo on impots.gouv.fr to help businesses—especially SMEs and the self-employed—identify compliant, authorized providers. As part of its electronic invoicing reform, the French government has adopted a model based on specialized, state... Read more
New document was uploaded: S4FiscalBackoffice Patch
Author: Dejan Šijačić
S4F backoffice patch is intended for users who have already installed S4F backoffice and are intended to update existing installations to latest version. To do so apply only patches that are marked with version number that is newer than your currently installed instance of backoffice. Please make sure to install all available patches sequentially (without skipping). This package contains instruction, release notes, changelog and software packages required for deployment of this software component. Read more
Subscribe to get access to the latest news, documents, webinars and educations.
Already subscriber? Login
New document was uploaded: EV-chargers from the Fiscalization Perspective in France
France
Author: Vukašin Santo
The purpose of this document is to explain rules regarding the treatment of EV chargers for electric vehicles in France in relation to fiscalization. The document will explain whether they are subjects of fiscalization or not, whether there are some special rules and regulations, or if there are some special rules. Read more
Subscribe to get access to the latest news, documents, webinars and educations.
Already subscriber? Login
Germany and France Update their Common E-Invoicing Standard
Public
Author: Ivana Picajkić
Germany and France will jointly update their hybrid e-invoice formats ZUGFeRD and Factur-X on 15 January 2026 to align with EN 16931 and support their upcoming B2B e-invoicing mandates. The new version expands technical capabilities, improves interoperability, and ensures full compatibility between both formats as Europe prepares for unified digital reporting under ViDA Germany and France have ann... Read more